top of page

Design solutions

Final design solutions

Design rationales | Logic Model Learner assessment

Our goal for the ECT orientation experience is to support new students in applying basic ECT knowledge and procedures to effectively plan for their first year in graduate school while also integrating themselves into the ECT student community and developing a strong support system while in the program. 
Introduction
We believe that it was important to approach the learning design as an experience not just a one-time event or lesson. There are four components, additional to the standard orientation session, we identified as crucial to the success of an orientation experience for new students. These are: 

All four components are additional elements to the standard orientation that will occur. This is more than just an experience for new students. The way we designed these elements allows students to still explore within a more guided environment. We thought this was very important for new students. It provides them with a learning community and opportunities for long-term social and informal learning. The design creates a community, outside the classroom, that will last throughout their graduate school experience. It also provides new students an easy way to understand the early logistics they need to complete and understand, which can often be an overwhelming process.

User flow storyboard
With the help of our new ECT program orientations, things start to get clearer and Luna feels comfortable and confident about her graduate life. Let's walk through her experiences. 

Luna is a 27-year-old First-year DMDL international student coming to the program in 2021 Fall. She has been a Marketing Assistant for an E-learning company for 2 years, while right now she is seeking for a career transition to Ed Tech as a professional. She earned her bachelor’s degree in the UK and this will be her first time studying in a U.S. university. She is not worried about her English skills, but she is more concerned about her life in New York when she comes - what to do with the visa process, what are things she needs to know ahead of time to perform better in college,  and how to make more connections within the program with the faculty and peers…? She has a lot of questions.

One_Congrats.png

STEP 1

 

First, Luna will receive her acceptance to NYU. 

Two_WelcomeEmail.png

STEP 2

 

After officially accepting, Luna will receive a “Welcome” email from the ECT Program Director (in July) which will share instructions to join ECT new student cohort Slack channel. In this same email, students will get access to the ECT website and in particular, the new student orientation guide.

Four_StepbyStep.png
Three_Video.png

STEP 4

 

Luna will then spend the next two months reviewing the ECT new student orientation guide and complete the five mandatory videos before the formal orientation session. These videos will show her the ECT space before even arriving on campus, prepare her for class registration, understand what the core classes are about, how to complete APA citations, etc. She’ll complete the necessary activities and explore the links below each video. 

Five_Slack.png

STEP 3

 

Luna will join the new student cohort Slack channel answering the provided prompt and introducing herself to her classmates. The Slackbot (Donut) will send a friendly reminder to Luna to checkout the ECT new student orientation guide. 

Activities
Our activities are designed to create stepping stones for students to feel more confident in deciding what choices will be the most appropriate for them in their academic career within ECT. The activities who choose create a guide on how to get started in the following sequence:
ECT New student website

After students accept their offer to begin studying with ECT, they receive an email via their personal and NYU emails with a link to the ECT New Student website. 

 
ECT logistics checklist

Students will be given a timeline and checklist of ECT logistical and communal tasks that they need to complete before classes begin.

 
Video tour guide

Students will navigate and complete mandatory videos on course requirements and the registration process. 

 
ECT Slack community
  • Students will sign up for ECT slack community, as well as explore and join specific channels for their cohorts.

  • Students will respond to prompts and reminders from the Slackbot (Donut)  within each channel (i.e. create a bio, icebreaker, answer polls, etc).

 
Meeting with the advisor

Students will create a checklist of items to talk about with their advisors using provided prompts. 

 
Live orientation sessions/events

Students will sign up for the live orientation session, ECT new student check-ins, and at least one ECT student mixer within their first semester.

 
Feedbacks

Students will provide feedback on their experiences in survey responses after each event and at the end of the semester check-in survey. 

Six_Social.png

STEP 5

 

Once Luna has moved to NYU and attended the in-person formal orientation session, she will attend at least one monthly mixer and one of the ECT student/faculty pulse check-ins. She finds the Donut reminders helpful in keeping track of all the  ECT events that she signed up for earlier in the semester. 

Media, technology
and resources 
Our team has focused on creating a framework that the ECT faculty members can use to create an impactful orientation process for new students. Our team is focused on using pre-existing technology to facilitate the delivery of information to students in a streamlined manner. Most of the media that the ECT faculty members will leverage already exist, but the new media touchpoints will need a working plan on how to create them.
Existing Media/ Resources:
  • New Student Checklists

  • Foundational courses overview presentations and syllabi 

  • Administrator (Jeneva) to monitor and curate content on slack

  • Alumni information and past portfolios

  • Linkedin Learning courses links

  • ECT and NYU calendar of events or newsletters

 

New Media/ Resources need to be added:
  • Video tutorial of the most common tools and logistical processes

  • Content outline or ideas for faculty or student a lead events 

  • Communication plan to send information to new students

  • Slackbot (Donut) that is already accessible to the NYU community 

 

Proposed existing technology to be revamped or used continually:
  • Slack 

  • ECT New Student Website

  • NYU Student Video Portal 

  • Google Calendar 

Learner 
Assessment
Our team is focused on creating a learning pathway to help new students identify key steps in order to feel prepared for their first year of graduate studies within ECT. Learning assessments are not applicable in our project, but rather an evaluation of whether or not new students were able to use the resources provided to map out their first-year experience.

We will be able to design a specific rubric to measure engagement and impact to the orientation overall experience by collecting qualitative and quantitative through measuring engagement levels in:

  • Responses and attendance to asynchronous activities led by ECT faculty members and students 

  • Completion rates on mandatory on-demand resources

  • Responses to a survey that will be sent out at the end of new students' first semester

  • New students’ end-of-year-gathering as an opportunity for the new students to share and showcase what they have learned and what has been valuable and impactful to them

Logic Model
We followed the “start at the end (impact)” method to finalize the impact first and work backward to outcomes, mediating processes and activities. 
logic model-final.png
Design Rationales
We believe that it was important to approach the learning design as an experience not just a one time event or lesson. There are four components we identified as crucial to the success of an orientation experience for new students. These are: 
  • Bite-size ECT new student Must-Watch Videos
  • New student cohort Slack channels
  • Interactive, collaborative Student Monthly Mixers (led by students) during the first semester of graduate school
  • ECT new student and faculty Pulse Check-In Coffee Chat
Bite-size ECT logistics videos

 

After talking to Maaike and Jeneva about the current orientation event and supporting resources, we were able to understand the context behind why they were designed the way they were. From both those conversations, there was one key element that stood out to us as incomplete: the new student orientation guide. This step by step guide is located on the new student page of the ECT website and includes the following sections: 

  • Step 1: Program Overview

  • Step 2: What Skills will you Need?

  • Step 3: Learn Key Concepts and Ideas

  • Step 4: Join Our Communities

  • Step 5: Explore the Larger NYU and NYC area

 

One thing Maaike mentioned that stood out to us was that “This wasn’t a very well thought out step by step process. They just came up with something out of nothing. They asked themselves how do we take advantage of the summer time to do stuff to prepare? They didn’t go through a design process at all. There was a huge constraint of new resources. It’s been out there for 5 years”  (M. Bouwmeester, personal communication, March 4, 2021). We definitely thought there was potential on this page but still wanted to learn more. Since Maaike and Jeneva also mentioned that they didn’t know whether or not students used this guide, we thought it was important to survey and learn from students themselves. Our survey results indicated that while half of the participants were aware of the guide and the other half weren’t, around 72% of participants, who were aware of the guide, didn’t find it helpful or didn’t have an opinion about it. When we asked students what type of resources they wish they had, the majority mentioned logistical resources like: 

  • Information about registering for classes

  • Tips on preparing for classes/expectations from the professors

  • Information about first semester courses

  • Learning from tenured students 

  • The technology they need to download

  • Campus resources 

 

With all this in mind, we came up with the ECT new student page revamp, which includes videos. This page would continue to follow the step by step guide but focused on the following categories: 

  • Welcome: Getting to know the community

    • Current student video introduces a “day in the life” with an attached form to ask them questions about time at ECT

    • Faculty member giving a tour of the ECT space and where to find important certain things in that space

    • Section for upcoming informal meet-ups with other new students facilitated by current students not faculty​

  • What to expect during your first semester? 

    • Video about how to prepare for your first advisor conversation

    • Current student video showing where to register for classes with an attached form to ask them questions about the process

    • Videos of faculty members talking about foundation courses with an attached form to ask them

  • Skillsets

    • Video about how to do APA citations with links to connect them to library resources

    • Video about how to read an academic journal

 

Each video will be created by current faculty or students and will be a maximum of 2 minutes long. These will be featured in a “TikTok” style format so students get a glimpse into what is important for them to know, without overwhelming them with information. Below each video will be adding links and exercises students can complete along with watching videos. Five of these videos and activities will be required for new students to complete. The idea is to add a personal touch, by having people within the ECT community create it, and curate the information that is important for new students.

Connecting learning theories and strategies 

 

Tell story: People like stories and “a really well-told story can stick with us for years” (Dirksen, 2015, p.133). As we were brainstorming how to present logistical information, which can oftentimes be mundane, we thought about the power of storytelling. Through the videos shared, new students are able to learn from current students and hear how they take on certain tasks important for a new student. It puts a voice to the activities that need to be performed and an opportunity to interact with them. In these videos, students and faculty can make these engaging by sharing funny anecdotes that humanizes the whole orientation experience. Aside from storytelling adding a personal and relatable touch, “stories usually involve sequenced events” and “logical flow involving cause and effect, and when you are recalling them, you can use that logic to recall what the events are” (Dirksen, 2015, p.134). Showing this logical flow through videos can help new students recall the process at later points of the semester or even their graduate school experience.


Show, Don’t Tell: We were very particular that we create a resource that is action-oriented and less of an information overload/dump. Videos allow new students to see and hear what happens as a result of doing this activity (i.e. taking this foundation class, registering for classes, reading an academic journal effectively etc.) but also allows them to follow along and complete tasks on their own. These videos are a guidance that gives students the confidence to draw their own conclusions and drive their own learning. This is important because “telling is smooth but showing has friction: It requires learners to make some of their own connections to interpret what’s going on” (Dirksen, 2015, p. 167). For example, a professor of Learning sciences can give a short introduction to what the course is all about. They can do this by showing some of the learning environments students will evaluate and theories they will study. This introduction may lead new students to curiosity and dive a little deeper by reading some additional materials, as well as reflect on their own learning experiences. 

Social & Informal Learning: We learned through our research that the learning experience for a new student is “not a straight line” (Dirksen, 2015, p. 245). So we asked ourselves, how can we think beyond the initial orientation session students attend? Through these short videos and step-by-step guide, students get to learn from peers and faculty outside a formal setting of a classroom or orientation session. The videos and relevant links are resources that are more flexible to reach. It’s hard for one person, like the program director or professor to answer all questions. This allows a more learning to happen in a more curated and focused way that is still social.

 

Multimedia Principle & Spatial Contiguity Principle: We wanted to create an orientation experience that would be engaging and designed in a way that would be fun and effective. For this reason, we thought about adding videos to our design instead of just works with additional links. We learned that "People learn better from words and pictures than from words alone.” (Mayer, 2009, p. 223). For our design, we will be including bite-sized videos along with a video description with links to additional resources for further exploration. The descriptions will be very brief to avoid cognitive overload. Videos will be next to descriptions and additional links because "Students learn better when corresponding words and pictures are presented near rather than far from each other on the page or screen” (Mayer, 2009, p. 135). This minimized the cognitive effort for new students trying to learn from each video. With it being easier, students can focus more on integration and further exploration. 

Technology and media affordance:

 

Videos: We decided stories are easily told through videos because it is a “much richer medium than either text and sound, it can also offer dynamic or moving pictures” (Bates, 2019 pg. 240). These videos will help new students learn about processes that may seem abstract when written. It can help demonstrate practical activities that are eventually to be carried out by the student themselves (i.e register for classes). Videos can also be a great medium to “demonstrate practical activities to be carried out by students, on their own” (Bates, 2019 pg. 242). Students are able to see how to complete certain procedural tasks and then do it on their own. 

 

Google Form: students can post questions that directly go to the person who created the video: This allows students to interact with others about the video and start building community. It also enables students to ask questions with the person who is talking in the video. Text in this context enhances opportunities for “communicability.” It also provides feedback for program instructors on what is making sense, what isn’t and what new students want to learn. If a lot of similar questions are coming in, program instructors can address it on the ECT Slack channels.

Student Monthly Mixer

 

A great number of students expressed their need of interfacing and meeting new students of their cohort. Due to the special situation of Spring and Fall 2020, most the program events and activities have to be rescheduled to be in virtual format or got canceled. Students mentioned that the lack of interpersonal communication under this special circumstance makes them feel unprepared about the semester and disconnected with their cohort and the ECT program.
 

The Student Monthly Mixer provides a chance for the new students in particular to get to know about everyone in the program, including tenured students, alumni and faculty members. This mixer would be student-orientated and will be held the last Thursday of each month, of which, the first Mixer of the semester will be specially designed for the new students to get to know each other, with a special theme or topic (eg. a Game night, Scavenger hunt, Museum day, Pizza lunch, Theme of the day, etc) that would engage everyone to attend for casual chat, informal networking or just have fun after or before class. 

 

The mixer is more than a one-time event, but a bridge that really brings all ECT members together to make connections and establish a sense of belonging to the ECT community. In the long run, students will be able to feel comfortable expressing themselves in the community and making proposals to voluntarily host events like this to strengthen ECT community bond, as well as practicing their project management skills and interpersonal skills.

Connecting learning theories and strategies 

Social constructivism/ Social Development Theory (Social Development Theory (Lev Vygotsky), 2018): Defining the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) can be important for ECT new students in terms of being able to identify useful resources that align with their core values and goals, thus being able to plan out their semesters in a more rational and wiser way. Student mixer also provides students with the opportunities to get to know members of the ECT community as More Knowledgeable Others as a way to understand their ZPD and what kind of extra help and information they will need in order to reach the next level goals. 

 

Extrinsic/intrinsic motivations (Dirksen, pp.123-158): Encouraging the students to participate in the student mixer by providing engaging activities, and extrinsic motivations such as free food, free ticket, free games, etc (depending on the department budget). The purpose of the student mixer is salient that students will benefit from it with newly-made connections, new information, or merely enjoyable experiences with the peers, therefore develop a sense of belonging to the ECT community that would become the intrinsic motivation to active participation and interaction in the future. 


Community of Practice (Lave and Wagne):  New students will interact with their cohort and the tenured students who very likely share a similar interest in education, media and design, that they can learn from each other by regular interactions both in-person or virtually through activities like this. There are also chances students might form sub CoP of more specific groups such as UX design, UX research, Instructional Design, Instructional game design, etc. 

Social Learning Theory (Bandura): Learning takes place in a social context. This can be best achieved by peer-to-peer learning by interacting, collaborating and discussing in a social setting like the student mixer. Students can learn from each other by sharing ideas and stories. 

Technology and media affordance:

 

In-person or Zoom live meetings are synchronous and communicative (Bates, 2019, pp. 207–215), which are considered as one of the best tools to build relationships. This meets the students’ need for interactions within peers, as well as building a safe and collaborative ECT community in the long run. 

Slack_logo_new.png
Slack Community

 

​Our survey that was sent out to current first-year students illustrates that new students are generally confused on where to ask for assistance for levels of getting set up for graduate school. Slack is a tool that ECT began using in 2020 to help bring different communities together in an online platform. However, there are not currently Slack channels dedicated to new students to ask questions or find information. Instead, ECT communicates to students in a sporadic nature through general email and Slack announcements. This makes it harder for new students to find the resources in the right place and at the right time in their orientation journey. 

New Student Slack channels can become a safe forum for ECT to provide relevant information to new students and answer questions in real-time. ECT can monitor the chat to see what types of questions and conversations to help current students and future students.

 

Introducing the  Slackbot (Donut) will help ECT push out information to new students in a more streamlined way. Emails are often overlooked by students, but Donut has the capability to track how many students have completed a task or responded to a prompt. The bot will communicate with students across 4 months (August-October). The communication will be more in the beginning and will slowly phase out. The messages sent out will correspond with deadlines on the new student checklist. Donut will also create more inclusivity by allowing students across different time zones to interact with information that is time-stamped and have accompanying threads of conversations that may be useful. 

Connecting learning theories and strategies 

 

​Learning community (Dirksen, pp. 243-255): effective learning community helps students to establish academic and social support networks and also helps to build a setting for community-based delivery of academic support programs.


Show, Don’t Tell  (Dirksen, pp. 161-193): By asking questions to the previous cohort or peers in ECT, students learn from others' journey of accomplishing one task, which engages students and makes them an active participant, which is important in the early days of this program.

Technology and media affordance:

 

Diffusions of innovation (Dirksen, pp. 215-227)

  • Relative advantage: The current slack channels are updated sporadically by faculty weekly. The revamped version will provide channels of different topics that are more student-centered, thus provide a safe place for students to get connected with each other, in particular new students. 

  • Compatibility: Still serves as the primary online communication tool within the ECT community

  • Complexity: Should be considered as easy once students familiarize with Slack. The Slackbot (Donut) is an add on to the Slack experience and does not require much effort to understand how to engage with it.

  • Observability: Available for everyone in the ECT community 

  • Trialability: Pilot with all the incoming cohort and have them joined in new student cohort channel and see the participation and engagement.

ECT new Student & Faculty Pulse Check-in

 

According to our stakeholders’ Maiike and Jeneva, new students have a major challenge of figuring out what courses will align with their career objectives after taking the foundational courses. Part of this challenge is the inability of faculty to have an open conversation with new students focused on career resources and opportunities. Currently, the only touch point for faculty is during new student orientation, which is extremely linear and inundated with ECT program information. Coffee Chats will provide a safe space for students to ask questions about courses they are interested in and how it may impact their career trajectory. This can also be used as a forum for faculty to acknowledge first-year students who have truly done amazing work and contributions to the ECT community.

 

ECT administrators can design check-ins with new students in the middle and end of their first year. The main objective of check-ins is to give faculty an opportunity to get a pulse check on how students have been adapting to graduate life and raise their awareness of opportunities and courses that align with their career objectives. The check-ins can be held virtually with a survey sent out soon after.

  • ECT New Student Coffee Chat's will be used as a platform for faculty to talk through new or interesting courses that students can take advantage of through ECT 

  • A point of celebration of achievements for high performing new students (such as portfolio contest winners, class projects that are actually being developed, etc. )

  • Create an environment where students can ask questions to faculty solely on what they are interested in for their 2nd and 3rd semester. 

Connecting learning theories and strategies 

Elaboration Theory (Reigeluth,1999): The theory states instruction should be organized from simple to complex for motivating learning. The check-ins are meant to give faculty the opportunity to expand on the courses being offered and celebrate the great work that they’ve identified from a few students. This can be done by providing an explanation of what the course entails, examples of projects from past students and soft and technical skills needed to perform well in certain courses.

Tell Story (Dirksen, J, pp. 123-140): Faculty will tell their own personal experiences with different topics and courses. This will help students understand if the course is truly aligned with their career goals and understand different faculty members instructing styles. 

Social constructivism(Vygotsky, 2012): Social constructivism focuses on the knowledge co-constructed through the interaction between participants based on their prior knowledge and experiences. As more knowable others, teachers and students who have taken the course according to their existing experience provide scaffolding to students who will take the course. Organizers play an essential role in stimulating interaction, such as providing scenarios to encourage learners to ask questions, encourage experienced learners to share, facilitate the negotiation, guide learners to make an agreement, or inspire learners' metacognition.

 
Technology and media affordance:

 

  • Similar as the mixer activities, Zoom live is the main method of our check-ins activity online, which is synchronous and communicative (Bates, 2019, pp. 207–215), can be served as a tool to build personal relations between the faculty and the students. Of course, faculty can record the Zoom meeting for people are unable to participate. In case, the recording of the meeting is asynchronous and broadcast (Bates, 2019, pp. 207–215).

  • Virtual settings will allow for more students and faculty members to join since there is a sense of uncertainty with how classes will commence next year. 

  • The online setting will allow for students to be more focused on the faculty members and use technology to translate conversations if needed. Faculty members can also field questions prior to the check-in to create a starting point for conversations. 

  • The only limitations would be the time constraints to go through the content and have open Q&A in a virtual environment.

Reference

Bates, T. (2019). Teaching in a Digital Age: Guidelines for Teaching and Learning (2nd ed.) [E-book]. https://opentextbc.ca/teachinginadigitalage/

Dirksen, J. (2015). Design for How People Learn (Voices That Matter) (2nd ed.) [E-book]. New Riders. https://learning-oreilly-com.proxy.library.nyu.edu/library/view/design-for-how/9780134211510/

Interview with Maaike Bouwmeester, ECT Program Director [Online interview]. (2021, March 4)

Mayer, R. E. (2009). Multimedia learning (2nd ed.). Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

Reigeluth, C. M. (1999). The elaboration theory: Guidance for scope and sequence decisions. Instructional design theories and models: A new paradigm of instructional   theory, 2, 425-453.

Social Development Theory (Lev Vygotsky). (2018, November 30). InstructionalDesign.Org. http://www.instructionaldesign.org/theories/social-development/

Vygotsky, L. S. (2012). Thought and language. MIT press.

© 2021. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page